Re: [xml-dev] Well-established uses of processing instructions?

[Rick Jelliffe <ricko@allette.com.au>]

Michael Kay wrote:

>I sometimes use processing instructions in a source document as instructions
>to a stylesheet, for example
>
><?insert-current-date-here?>
>
>One could of course use an element just as well; but that means changing the
>schema/DTD, which one might have no control over.
>
>This is not really something I would recommend: it's very likely that other
>applications designed to process XML conforming to this schema will fall
>over when they encounter this undocumented PI. But it can be handy all the
>same!
>  
>
Why would they fall over?  Typically unless you specifically do something to
make your application act on PIs, they are stripped or ignored. 

Applications that fall over when they discover a PI they don't 
understand are
improperly written.

But PIs used to generate text are non-portable, and so appropriate for 
documents
that are being pre-processed. Probably what should be used is  entities:

<!ENTITY current-data SYSTEM "http://www.eg.com/dynamic?get-current-date";>

because the information is data content.

Cheers
Rick

Cheers
Rick Jelliffe