Karl, Farrukh, All,
I neglected to mention in my last post, that I agree that protecting
us from Spam is essential, and welcome, and my comments have no
relation to that, which I agree is beneficial.
Thanks,
Rex
At 10:06 AM -0400 9/26/03, Farrukh Najmi wrote:
>Karl F. Best wrote:
>
>>Rex, Farrukh:
>>
>>It's been the case for quite some time now that a person must
>>subscribe to the comment list in order to post a comment. I know
>>that it sounds silly to require this, but we've got to keep the
>>spam off the lists and out of the archives, and the only other
>>method is to moderate all of the comment lists and I haven't heard
>>anyone volunteer to handle them all.
>
>Having to manage several lists on the web I now completely
>understand the rationale Karl presents for requiring subsription to
>all OASIS mailing lists. This has been the most effective way to
>eliminate automatically generated spam on a mailing list in my
>experience.
>
>I certainly feel comfortable that this policy is to protect us from
>SPAM and not motivated by any other sinister motives.
>
>Thanks for the explaination Karl.
>
>>
>>
>>We are putting together a web form that can be used to submit
>>comments; I hope that we can launch this pretty quickly (we're also
>>working on a couple other things at the same time). Once we have
>>this then the guy on the street won't need to subscribe in order to
>>send just one comment.
>>
>>-Karl
>>
>>
>>
>>Rex Brooks wrote:
>>
>>>Folks,
>>>
>>>I caught this on the ebxml registry list and while I have not
>>>checked on the actual procedures in place with regard to the
>>>current manifestation of OASIS poolicy on the public comment
>>>lists, I find this unexceptional. With apologies to OASIS, I have
>>>to say that I find the current policy to have, in effect, killed
>>>the public comment lists, to the detriment of the TCs and OASIS at
>>>large at a time when many of us are trying our best to improve the
>>>stature of OASIS in the arena of standards bodies. This is a
>>>shame, and I must admit that I have, in effect, also thrown in the
>>>towel because it is a fight that I doubt we can win. The official
>>>mind is made up, and regardless of the rationale, the effect may
>>>already be irreversible. After more than two years of working on
>>>the Human Markup Language, I have concluded that one would be
>>>foolish to stand in the line of fire when any human being or group
>>>of humans decides to shoot itself in the foot.
>>>
>>>As Pogo observed, "We have met the enemy and it is us."
>>>
>>>Ciao, but sadly,
>>>Rex
>>>
>>>At 10:00 PM -0600 9/25/03, Monica Martin wrote:
>>>
>>>>Farrukh Najmi wrote:
>>>>
>>>>>It seems that the regrep-comments list is now requiring that the
>>>>>sender be subscribed? This does not seem right. Should we not
>>>>>allow an external commenter to send comments unimpeded? I could
>>>>>not even figure out how to tell Mei Zhao to subscribe. Kathryn,
>>>>>could you please look into a solution to this recurring problem.
>>>>>
>>>>>In any event the issue/suggestion below seems to make good sense
>>>>>from an OO stand point.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>mm1: On the suggestion, sounds reasonable. On the issue about
>>>>comment list, I seem to remember some kind of an issue with Kavi
>>>>and the fact that the comment signup was either not intuitive or
>>>>didn't work correctly. The webmaster should know on the system
>>>>aspects. As to the change in process, I can't answer there.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>To unsubscribe from this mailing list (and be removed from the
>>>>roster of the OASIS TC), go to
>>>>http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/regrep/members/leave_workgroup.php.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>
>
>--
>Farrukh
--
Rex Brooks
GeoAddress: 1361-A Addison, Berkeley, CA, 94702 USA, Earth
W3Address: http://www.starbourne.com
Email:
Tel: 510-849-2309
Fax: By Request
