[ebxml-msg] More Editiorial Comments (Fw: duplicateElimination and7.5.2 & others)

I agree with the following editorial comments from Michael Wang.

-Arvola

-----Original Message-----
From: Michael Wang <>
To: Arvola Chan <>
Date: Tuesday, November 27, 2001 6:24 PM
Subject: duplicateElimination and 7.5.2 & others


>section 7.5.2 item 2a.  (line1663-1667)
>this does not fall inline with my current understanding of use
>of duplicateElimination attribute.
>
>it should say: MUST NOT deliver to application ONLY WHEN
>duplicateElimination is TRUE.
>
>this section (7.5.2) failed to address the possibility of no
>AckRequested BUT duplicateElimination is present.
>
>also, should there be mention of QualityOfServiceInfo element
>(& hence duplicateElimination attribute) under 7.3?  it is
>mentioned in 7.4 but the context is a bit different.  just
>like AckRequestd is repeated multiple times in 7.3.1 and 7.4.2.
>(7.4.2 is really not needed.)
>
>7.4.7's reference of SyncReplyMode should probably be qualified
>that this is defined in CPP/A.
>
>same comment on duplicateElimination=false && AckRequested is
>not present is not considered for section 7.5.6

>-mw