Error reporting Ed note

Section 6.6 in 
WD16:

 

an Ed note was not 
fully resolved. I guess the first bullet point needs clarification that SOAP 
Faults must always be generated for "failure" severity level, and that the Fault 
message (for ebms processing)  must also include eb:Messaging header with 
eb:Error element(s).

 

The first bullet 
could then be:

 

Reporting with Fault Sending: An MSH MUST 
generate a SOAP Fault for reporting ebMS processing errors of severity 
"failure", which prevent further message processing. This Fault 
must comply with SOAP Fault processing, i.e. 
be sent back as an HTTP response in 
case the message in error was over an HTTP 
request. In case of ebMS processing errors (see 6.7.1) the Fault message 
MUST also include the eb:SignalMessage/eb:Error element in the eb:Messaging 
header. 

 

So Fault "detail" is 
not required to be used here , as it is always assumed that an eb:Error header 
element will give details (e.g. with refToMessageInError), at least for Faults 
generated by the ebms processing module (not required for Security or 
Reliability modules)

 

For the last 
bullet:

 

Error message: an 
ebMS signal message sent from one MSH to another, which contains at least one eb:Error element. Such a reporting action 
is modeled by Send and Receive abstract 
operations over such a message.

 

we 
could add:

 

The reporting message must always be combined with a SOAP 
Fault unless the severity is "warning".

 

Jacques