Re: ACC or ABIE? (Was Re: [regrep-cc-review] Association Core Components - Represent withAssociations)

[Forwarding to our listserv]

<Quote>
I would say that "ResidenceAddress. Details" fits the 2nd
option.
</Quote>

Thanks Diego - let's say for the moment that "ResidenceAddress.
Details"  is an ABIE. We can create an ABIE from an ACC by classifying
it according to one of the 8 context categories (and adding the Object
Class Qualifier). Would the addition of "Residence" fall under one of
the 8 context categories? Or do we need to amend our handling of the
ACC->ABIE transition to state that it can occur from:

(a) Classification according to one of the 8 context categories (plus
addition of Object Class Qualifier), or
(b) Simply the addition of an Object Class Qualifier (in which case no
classification would be involved)

Joe

Diego Ballvé wrote:
> 
> Chiusano Joseph wrote:
> >
> > Thanks to Monica for her feedback - please see comments below.
> >
> > <Quote1>
> > >With this in mind, do folks agree that it would be valuable
> > to create >an entity (a type of an ACC) in the registry called
> > >"ResidenceAddress. Details", that can be re-usable in many
> > cases, >thereby alleviating the
> > >need to constantly re-create it on-the-fly?
> > >
> > mm1: One impact you have to think about, and has been raised
> > by CCSD, is
> > if the ResidenceAddress. Details has the same attributes
> > which supports
> > the later discussion if it could also be an ABIE.
> > </Quote1>
> >
> > That's a great point, which I also brought up to Alan Stitzer of the
> > CCTS Team. Is "ResidenceAddress. Details" an ACC or an ABIE? (or
> > something in-between?) In the p.16 CCTS example it lists
> > "US_ResidenceAddress. Details" as an ABIE, so could "ResidenceAddress.
> > Details" really be an ABIE? If yes, then what context category does it
> > fall under?
> 
> There might be an "ResidenceAddress. Details" ACC and
> a and a "ResidenceAddress. Details" ABIE, and the ABIE could
> be the realization/contextualization of the idea (ACC). In
> practice we (@Republica) assumed that some BIEs would be
> context specific and some would probably fit all contexts.
> I would say that "ResidenceAddress. Details" fits the 2nd
> opion.
> 
> Despite we can have ACC and ABIE with same name and actually
> related (InstanceOf?), using the same RegistryObject for both
> might not be possible, the main reason being the fact that we
> can have multiple BIEs for the same CC.
> 
> Diego