RE: [security-services] Groups - liberty-architecture-overview-v1 .1.pdfuploaded

Prateek,

Thanks for your help in clarifying these
issues. I do however have some remaining concerns. For the sake of those
of us who are not going to search the LA website for press releases, please
place all relevant documents on the SS TC document repository. By this
I mean, if documents are in the repository that contain statements about
IPR that are modified by other documents they should also be available
in the repository.

I've never said that there were IPR
conditions that have been violated. I said that it remains unclear, based
on the email message that accompanied the submission, whether the submission
meets the conditions for OASIS. The specific item that I do not see fully
acknowledged in the email message is Item #1 in Section OASIS.IPR.3.1.
I acknowledge that this may be covered in documents that are not easily
found on the SS TC website. Perhaps you can be kind enough to show me where?

I don't think I've suggested that the
OASIS Board needs to oversee every action of the TC. However, in the case
where the TC is placing documents into its repository that have unclear
IPR restrictions it would be helpful if the OASIS Board made some statement
as to whether these documents have been determined to have met the criteria
for submission to OASIS.

Thanks again,

Mike

"Mishra, Prateek" <>

10/18/2003 03:34 PM
        

        To:
       Michael McIntosh/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, "Mishra,
Prateek" <>

        cc:
       "' '" <>,
"' '" <>

        Subject:
       RE: [security-services] Groups - liberty-architecture-overview-v1
               .1.pdf
uploaded

 

 

 

Hi Prateek, 

Thanks for sending this, I missed it before. It appears that this unsigned
email message comes from several OASIS SS TC members who also happen to
be LA members. Has the TC received any definitive statements directly from
the LA Board? 

         
<Prateek>

         
This is a matter of public record. Please see:

         
http://www.projectliberty.org/press/releases/2003-04-11.html

 

         The
formal SSTC minutes of Aprl 15, 2003 describes the submission and acceptance
of the contribution.

         
http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/security-services/200304/msg00128.html

 

 

         
</Prateek>

 

Also, even if this submission has received the LA Board's approval it remains
unclear whether it meets the conditions for submission under OASIS. There
are several specific conditions required for submission to OASIS that do
not appear to have been addressed by the email message. Please see: http://www.oasis-open.org/who/intellectualproperty.php

         
<Prateek>

         
 I am sorry I do not follow this line of reasoning. What are the specific
conditions that have not been met? To my knowledge all of the conditions
in  http://www.oasis-open.org/who/intellectualproperty.php
are met by the submissions. Could you please point to the specific portions
(section numbers, text) of http://www.oasis-open.org/who/intellectualproperty.php
that you believe have been violated? 

 

           
   </Prateek>

 

Has the OASIS Board made it's position clear on this specific set of documents?
I suggest that any relevant statements related to IPR be collocated with
the documents in the archive.

 

        <Prateek>

         I
am sorry I do not understand your question. The SSTC is an autonomous group
that functions under the rules given in http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/process.php.
Are you suggesting that the OASIS board must give an opinion on day-to-day
TC decisions? 

 

       </Prateek>

Thanks, 

Mike 

 
"Mishra, Prateek"
<>

10/17/2003 09:31 PM

        

        To:        Michael McIntosh/Watson/IBM@IBMUS,
"' '" <>

        cc:        "'
'" <>

        Subject:        RE: [security-services]
Groups - liberty-architecture-overview-v1        .1.pdf
uploaded

 

http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/security-services/200304/msg00072.html

-----Original Message-----

From: Michael McIntosh

To: 

Cc: 

Sent: 10/17/2003 8:52 PM

Subject: Re: [security-services] Groups -

liberty-architecture-overview-v1.1.pdf uploaded

Can someone please show me where this TC has been given the rights to

prepare derivative works or reproduce portions of this document? 

This document explicitly forbids these actions. 

Thanks, 

Mike

To unsubscribe from this mailing list (and be removed from the roster of
the OASIS TC), go to http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/security-services/members/leave_workgroup.php.