Re: [security-services] Liberty IPR Issues (was: Liberty ID-FF 1.2 submission to the SSTC)

Anthony Nadalin wrote:
>>I did read the document.  Please show the wording that you think provides the derivative rights.
> 
> Its pretty clear, in "Each Author grants permission to OASIS and OASIS
> members the right to copy, display, perform, modify and distribute the Web
> Services Security ("WS-Security") draft specification and to authorize
> others to do the foregoing, in any medium without fee or royalty, for the
> purpose of further developing the WS-Security specification in the WSSTC as
> set forth in the draft WSS TC charter". I suggest you take this to your IP
> folks or are you asking for derivative rights for what the WSS-TC creates ?

This has to do with copyright (the text of the specification as 
submitted), not patent licensing.  Are you saying that this is what has 
not been secured in the case of the Liberty contributions?  If so, I 
don't think it's true:

http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/security/ipr.php
"Our Liberty Alliance Agreements grant, with board approval, copyright 
licenses needed to prepare derivative works, among other activities, as 
required by the OASIS IPR Policy, section 3.1(1)."

	Eve
-- 
Eve Maler                                        +1 781 442 3190
Sun Microsystems                            cell +1 781 354 9441
Web Products, Technologies, and Standards    eve.maler @ sun.com