Saml Metadata Extension for Query Requesters Spec

Title: Message

Scott, some 
minor comments on these as you move this into Public Review 
form.

 

- line 147: PDP 
requesters

 

- line 167: I 
believe you're missing the ActionNamespace element definition as 
anyURI.

 

- line 125: typo 
"atribute".

 

 

Observations (don't 
care either way, just curious):

 

- line 79, you 
abstracted out the query requester items, but this was not done for the 
authorities. I believe this is correct, but was wondering if staying consistent 
with the current metadata scheme makes sense.

 

- line 145, along 
the same lines as above, authz decision authority was called "PDPDescriptor" and 
not "AuthzDecisionAuthorityDescriptor", I believe your proposal of 
AuthzDecisionQueryDescriptor is correct, but for consistency, did you consider 
"PEPDescriptor"?

 

- line 83, is it 
just typical that for attributes, we define new ones within the schema (query 
namespace) as opposed to use the one from metadata. Specically I'm looking at 
the query:WantAssertionsSigned attribute vs. 
md:WantAssertionsSigned.

 

Tom.

 

Thomas Wisniewski
Software Architect 
Phone: (201) 
891-0524 
Cell: (201) 248-3668 

  
EntrustÒ 
Securing Digital Identities
& Information