Re: SV: SV: [ubl-dev] UBL OrderResponseCode

Martin,

By the way for the LineStatusCode should it not be listID="1229" ACTION REQUEST/NOTIFICATION, CODED

http://www.unece.org/trade/untdid/d96a/trsd/trsdlin.htm

regards

Danny    

  
 
 
    From: Danny Gaethofs <>
 To: Martin Forsberg <>; UBL-Dev <> 
 Sent: Monday, October 7, 2013 12:08 PM
 Subject: Re: SV: SV: [ubl-dev] UBL OrderResponseCode
  
 

Martin,

This means the way that it is communicated is as follows:

<cbc:OrderResponseCode
listID=”UNCL1225”>30</cbc:OrderResponseCode>

Let us have a look at another field, the LineStatusCode.

In the Peppol variant it probably looks as follows:

<cbc:LineStatusCode
listID=”UNCL1225”>29</cbc:LineStatusCode>

In the UBL
 variant is looks as follows:

<cbc:LineStatusCode listAgencyID="UBL" listName="Line Status">NoStatus</cbc:LineStatusCode>

Why is it not done conform the CEN/BII Guidelines Data Format ?

<cbc:LineStatusCode listID=”1225” listAgencyID="6">29</cbc:LineStatusCode>

2.1.3 Code types 

Code types are used to specify allowed values in elements (BBIEs) as well as for
 lists of options. 

Code types are different to IDs in that allowed values have standardized meanings that can be known by the 

recipient. 

BII uses two types of codes: 

- Defined codes, based on standards such as ISO or UN/CEFACT 

- Bilaterally agreed codes. 

Bilaterally agreed codes are usually used without attributes but standardised codes list may require 

metadata that can be given in attributes. 

When using Code lists for code values in BII instances, the attribute listID and listAgencyID are mandatory 

The following table shows the use of attributes for Code Types that are issued by third
 parties (other
 than 

UBL). 

listID Identifier for the code list 3055 Mandatory. 

listAgencyID Identifier for the issuer of the code list 6 Mandatory. 

Kind regards

Danny Gaethofs

  

 

 
    From: Martin Forsberg <> To: Danny Gaethofs <>; UBL-Dev <>  Sent: Thursday, October 3, 2013 3:40 PM Subject: SV: SV: [ubl-dev] UBL OrderResponseCode  
 

Hi,
 

  
 

The Order-specification is just about to be finalized (one or two more weeks). I will make sure that the publication
 will be announced on this list.
 

  
 

/Martin
 

  
 

Från: Danny Gaethofs [mailto:]

Skickat: den 3 oktober 2013 15:28
Till: Martin Forsberg; UBL-Dev
Ämne: Re: SV: [ubl-dev] UBL OrderResponseCode
 

  
 

Thanks Martin,
 

  
 

Can you point the way to the implementation guide ?
 

  
 

I have been looking at all the deliverables 
 

http://www.cenbii.eu/deliverables/cwa-16562-post-award/
 

  
 

and at 
 

http://www.peppol.eu/peppol_components/peppol-post-award-resources
 

  
 

but somehow I do not seem to find the document you are refering to.
 

  
 

regards
 

Danny
 

  
 

From: Martin Forsberg <>
To: Danny Gaethofs <>; UBL-Dev <>

Sent: Thursday, October 3, 2013 1:54 PM
Subject: SV: [ubl-dev] UBL OrderResponseCode
 

  
 

Hi Danny,
 

 
 

In the PEPPOL implementation guide for order and order response (based on CENBII) we use the following codes:
 

 
 

27 – Not Accepted

 

29 – Accepted
 

30 -- Accepted with amendment in detail section
 

 
 

And listID = UNCL1225
 

 
 

Best regards
 

Martin Forsberg
 

 
 

 
 

Från: Danny Gaethofs [mailto:]

Skickat: den 3 oktober 2013 13:23
Till: UBL-Dev
Ämne: [ubl-dev] UBL OrderResponseCode
 

 
 

Dear all,
 

 
 

The OrderResponseCode has been added to UBL 2.1 - at least what I understand or can find about this -- some questions:
 

 
 

- what was / is used in UBL 2.0 to exchanges the status of the order response : rejected, accepted , accepted with amendmends ?
 

 
 

 
 

- what is the preferrerd listAgencyID or name and what are the listID's 
 

Can the UN/EDIFACT  values used in the BGM 1225 be used and what would then be the listAgencyID ?
 

 
 

1225=29 Accepted without amendment, Referenced message is entirely accepted.
 

BGM/1225=29
 

1225=4 Change. Message containing items (e.g. line items, goods items, Customs items, equipment items) to be changed in a previously sent message.
 

BGM/1225=4
 

1225=34 Accepted with amendment. The referenced message is accepted but amended.
IF NO delivery date LIN+DTM+69 is available 1225=45 Accepted with reserve. >> no delivery date known
 

BGM/1225=34 OR 45
 

 
 

 
 

kind regards
 

Danny Gaethofs