RE: [wsfed] RE: WSFED TC Minutes, July 24, 2007

Coorection,

Anil 
from RedHat did not loose voting status

thanks

abbie

 

From: Barbir, Abbie (CAR:1A14) 
Sent: 
Wednesday, July 25, 2007 3:52 PM
To: Greg Carpenter; 

Cc: ; Chris Kaler; Mike 
Kaiser
Subject: [wsfed] RE: WSFED TC Minutes, July 24, 
2007

All,

 

Fixed 
an error in attendance

 

new 
list

 

Will Hopkins;BEA Systems, 
Inc.

Hal Lockhart;BEA 
Systems, Inc.

Denis Pilipchuk;BEA 
Systems, Inc.

Mike 
Kaiser;IBM

Larry Rogers;Lockheed 
Martin*

Greg 
Carpenter;Microsoft Corporation

Colleen 
Evans;Microsoft Corporation

Chris Kaler;Microsoft 
Corporation

Arun Nanda;Microsoft 
Corporation

Don Schmidt;Microsoft 
Corporation

Norman Brickman;Mitre 
Corporation*

Abbie 
Barbir;Nortel

Steve 
Carter;Novell*

Doug 
Earl;Novell*

Mary McRae;OASIS 
*

Rich Levinson;Oracle 
Corporation

Robin Martherus;Ping 
Identity Corporation*

Anil Saldhana;Red 
Hat

Gerry Woods;SOA 
Software Inc.

Don Adams;TIBCO 
Software Inc.

Kent Spaulding;Tripod 
Technology Group, Inc.

David Staggs;Veterans 
Health Administration

 

status change remain the same

thanks

abbie

 

From: Greg Carpenter 
[mailto:] 
Sent: Wednesday, July 25, 2007 9:14 
AM
To: 
Cc: ; 
Barbir, Abbie (CAR:1A14); Chris Kaler; Mike Kaiser
Subject: WSFED TC 
Minutes, July 24, 2007

WSFED TC Minutes, July 24, 2007

 

Summary of new Action Items:

AI-2007-07-24-01 – Chairs: update TC calendar to reflect bi-weekly meeting 
decision

 

1. Call to order/roll call

Status Change: 

Lost Voting Status 
:   Jeff Bohren, BMC; Anil Saldhana, RedHat

Gained Voting Status 
:·       Don Schmidt, M/S; Will Hopkins, BEA; 
Robin Martherus, Ping Identity 

Attendance: 

Will Hopkins;BEA Systems, Inc. 

Hal Lockhart;BEA Systems, Inc. 
Denis Pilipchuk;BEA Systems, Inc. 

Mike Kaiser;IBM 
Anil John;Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L... 

Larry Rogers;Lockheed Martin* 
Greg Carpenter;Microsoft Corporation 

Colleen Evans;Microsoft Corporation 
Chris Kaler;Microsoft Corporation 

Arun Nanda;Microsoft Corporation 
Don Schmidt;Microsoft Corporation 

Norman Brickman;Mitre Corporation* 
Abbie Barbir;Nortel 
Steve 
Carter;Novell* 
Doug Earl;Novell* 
Mary McRae;OASIS * 
Rich 
Levinson;Oracle Corporation 
Robin Martherus;Ping Identity Corporation* 

Gerry Woods;SOA Software Inc. 
Don Adams;TIBCO Software Inc. 
Kent 
Spaulding;Tripod Technology Group, Inc. 
David Staggs;Veterans Health 
Administration 

 

2. Reading/Approving minutes of last meeting 

http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsfed/email/archives/200707/msg00003.html

 

Adopted unanimously.

 

3. TC Logistics (10 minutes or less)

 

The TC will maintain a bi-weekly meeting schedule until further 
notice.

AI: TC chairs to update meeting calendar to reflect bi-weekly 
schedule

 

4. Issues list

http://docs.oasis-open.org/wsfed/issues/Issues.xml

 

a) Review of action items

None

 

b) Issues in Review status

  None.

 

c) New issues

  None.

 

 

d) Active issues

 

i004 - Transitive closure spec dependencies

In progress. No status change.

 

i005 - Complex claim data types

In progress. No status change.

 

i006 - WSFED FAQ

In progress. No status change.

 

i007 - Claim Type references

In progress. No status change.

 

i008 - Sign-out notification and priority

Don Schmidt will send email summarizing his comments to the TC list.

 

f) Pending issues

  None.

 

5. AOB

 

Larry Rogers: Is it good practice to narrow scope and use MUST/SHALL or is 
it better to leave things more open?

Chris: MUST/SHALL is sometimes preferable for interopability but limits 
entensibility and future options.

Hal: Agree – there is no universal answer. If there is a specific instance 
of a  normative wording issue that specific instance should be brought to 
the TC for consideration.

Larry: Good, that’s the answer I was hoping for.

Don Schmidt:  The case of an  STS returning sign-out completion 
messages is a case in point--it is not always possible and a MUST would be too 
restrictive.

 

6. Adjournment