Re: [xml-dev] .net 6.0 XSD validator bug

From
Mukul Gandhi <>
To
Jirka Kosek <>
Date
2022-03-30T07:07:15Z
ID
<CANGHzgDjQNNBKGbJYX+AjD9PxT_SFn6s2h8qhf-=>
Thread
Re: [xml-dev] .net 6.0 XSD validator bug
On Tue, Mar 29, 2022 at 2:37 PM Jirka Kosek <[email protected]> wrote:
Perhaps not a bug but inconvenient behaviour.

If you change namespace of your XML instance then validator can't find
schema for this namespace. And in this situation validator behaviour
varies -- some will complain about missing declarations and some will
skip validation of element for which there is no corresponding schema
declaration.

IMHO, that's a sure bug.

We're asking an XSD validator, to validate XML instance document x with XSD document y, and tell us whether the result is valid or invalid. If the XSD validator reports a valid outcome, and if the validation outcome should have been invalid, then that's a bug. 
 

--
Regards,
Mukul Gandhi