kmip-interop-tech — archive

KMIP Interop Call Minutes - 18Dec2015

From: Tony Cox
To: [email protected]
Date: Mon, 04 Jan 2016 10:32:00 -0000

2016 KMIP Interop Participant Call #1a - 18th December 2015 Introduction: Using the OASIS Infrastructure has provided Tony with a few more logistics difficulties but should be mostly resolved now and workable. Tony apologized for the late/last minute nature of the call - it will be re-run on Monday for those who cannot attend today. Roll Call: Cryptsoft - Tony C, Tim H, Greg S Fornetix - Jeff B, Gerry S HPE - Steve W, Nathan T, Vincent T, Qwong ? SafeNet - David F Agenda: Agenda review Minutes review Interop test scope and overview Interop Test timing The rules Adjourn Motion to approve Agenda: Tim H Moves, Jeff B Seconds, No objections, abstentions or comments. Interop test scope, overview, timing and rules: Tony walked through the process document (v1.2 as circulated): - All participants to accept the process via email to the list (or raise objections on the call or to Tony privately. - Reviewed the scope of the test being KMIP v1.2 (test cases & profile test cases), KMIP v1.3 (test cases & profile test cases), whatever KMIP v1.4 participants can agree on. - Minimum requirement will be to perform something (even just a single operation) against each other for KMIP 1.2 or above. - Folks visiting the booth are used to see the latest and greatest functionality and 1.3 was demonstrated in 2015 - we are looking to show some form of v1.4 functionality in 2016 to show the TCs latest work per the original TC decision to do the interop back in April. David F: Raised a concern that SafeNet may not be participating given their limited KMIP support. Tim: Minimum bar will be ensuring each client can interact with each server and vice versa. David F: Indicated some basic 1.2 support that matches the original SafeNet KMIP 1.1 support will be in place. X-NONE X-NONE Tim H: Given what David has indicated then SafeNet will support at least Query, and the technical requirements will be met - it is purely a marketing/product management decision to demonstrate more functionality to show in the result graphs that are published. to show in the result graphs that are published. Tony: This would enable SafeNet to participate. Tony to continue speaking with Stephen Kingston (SafeNet) to check the status. Tony walked through the remainder of the process document: - Claims sheet will be circulated soon. - Test sheets to be generated from completed claims forms like in 2014. - Ensure all discussions and content within the participant group is kept strictly confidential. Publications back to the TC will be done by agreement following the completion of testing. - Discussed escalation on interop failures to participant group then the Interop Subcommittee, then the KMIP TC. Steve W: highlighted a few test cases that were problematic last year as there are multiple correct answers (those that respond with the server behaviour). All agreed we'll clarify the expected result prior to test so the set of tests that are basically variations are clearly noted. Tony: - Dates are tight - start date is Jan 11th. Claim sheets should be returned by COB Friday 25th Pacific. Walked through full set of dates. Adjourn: Jeff B Seconds, Tim H Moves, , No objections, abstentions or comments. Meeting adjourned 14:34 PST -- 2015-02-11T02:35:00Z 1 26 152 1 1 177 14.00 X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 Tony Cox KMIP Interop Lead [email protected]