OASIS Mailing List ArchivesView the OASIS mailing list archive below
or browse/search using MarkMail.

 


Help: OASIS Mailing Lists Help | MarkMail Help

 


 

   RE: [xml-dev] [OT] Tim Bray on Slashdot

[ Lists Home | Date Index | Thread Index ]

It's a good article, I just don't buy the conclusion 
as much as I like the sentiment. 

There are plenty of reasons to use WinForms or something 
like it.  Keeping all the business rules on the server 
isn't always the best way to balance the system or manage 
it.  Being inside the HTML framework when trying to 
do 3D turned out to be a pretty crummy solution and I 
suspect for anything near real time and critical, that 
becomes the case.  Few notice it because there aren't 
that many real time/mission critical apps out there 
on the web.  What happens is that the costs of these 
apps for any sizable organization stays fairly constant 
and fairly high.  What we have done and in fact most 
of our industry (public safety) is doing is learning 
how to use the browser for what it is good for and 
get costs down that way.  It's been very effective. 
We sell lots of I/NetViewer applications.  Where browsing 
and light interaction is needed, works great, less filling.

What the web has contributed:

1.  Awareness of the costs and complexities of using 
industry specific network protocols.  What will be 
interesting is to see if REST is up to Real Time.

2.  Awareness that lack of data standards is keeping 
costs high and interoperation (at both the machine 
and human levels) unreliable.  Unfortunately, it still 
isn't as easy as some think to design an XML language 
that is suitable to all media but it is dang near 
unthinkable without it.

3.  Regional Automated Integrated Networks (Let it Rain).
A good idea who's time is not only come, it is past due.

I wonder why operating systems have never become no-cost 
commodities or if they ever will.  LINUX suggests they 
can although it isn't really no-cost.  I believe this 
is the area for innovative thinking in the business model. 
If it is true that commoditization or even 'just one 
winner' means we lose innovation, we have to live with 
the fact of big landowners and sharecroppers.  On the 
other hand, no one sharecrops these days just as the 
family farm is disappearing because technology still 
favors the well-heeled.  No combines; no harvest.

It is a tough row to hoe if you have to feed the world 
and clothe the poor yet still be tasty and stylish.

len

From: Tim Bray [mailto:tbray@textuality.com]

David Megginson wrote:

>  This
> will be a good chance to see if Tim's server can withstand the
> /. effect.

Heh; third time on slashdot.  Ongoing is entirely static HTML pages via 
apache, it's a sub-1GHz Intel box of some sort and the system load 
rarely hits 0.1 even under a fresh slashdotting.  This is a Sunday 
slashdotting which is nothing compared to a weekday-morning hit; every 
geek in the world does /. end-to-end when they first sit down at their 
desks, near as I can tell.




 

News | XML in Industry | Calendar | XML Registry
Marketplace | Resources | MyXML.org | Sponsors | Privacy Statement

Copyright 2001 XML.org. This site is hosted by OASIS