OASIS Mailing List ArchivesView the OASIS mailing list archive below
or browse/search using MarkMail.


Help: OASIS Mailing Lists Help | MarkMail Help



   Re: [xml-dev] W3C suckered by Microsoft?

[ Lists Home | Date Index | Thread Index ]

Bob Wyman wrote:

>Dennis Sosnoski wrote:
>>I think dramatic change is needed, and a victory 
>>by Eolas looks to me to be the event most likely 
>>to bring about such change. The amount of money 
>>involved is pocket change for Microsoft in any case.
>	So, you're saying we should sit back and "sacrifice" several
>hundred million dollars of Microsoft's money and mess up their product
>plans in order to teach folk that the problem of bad patents is real? 
Yup. Sounds like it's worth a try to me.

>	Sorry, I'm just not quite that cold. Neither Microsoft nor
>anyone else, no matter how small or large, deserves to be "sacrificed"
>in such a manner. In this country (the United States) we generally
>work on the idea that everyone has a right to justice and equal
>treatment in our courts. These rights aren't properly suspended when
>it becomes convenient to create an "example" -- even if, as you
>suggest, the money wouldn't be a big loss for Microsoft. In the
>country where this case is being pursued, the goal is to provide
>justice to *all* -- independent of their means.
Hmmm. Tell that to the Muslim charities shut down because some of the 
same people who donated to them also donated to organizations our 
government has labeled as "terrorist". In any case, I'm not arguing 
against the "right to justice and equal treatment in our courts." If 
anything, I'm saying let this take its course. You appear to be the one 
arguing in favor of intervention from outside the court system in order 
to invalidate the judgment of the courts.

You appear to be offended by what you see as a lack of justice in the 
outcome of this case. Unfortunately, our legal system here in these 
United States has very little to do with justice. It's a system of laws 
enacted by career politicians who are rarely if ever motivated by 
anything I'd see as the public interest. This is not (just) an 
indictment of the United States, though - the same holds true, with 
minor variations, in every other country I'm aware of.

>	But, it's hard to tell where people are from in mailing
>lists... Perhaps you're not an American? Or, maybe if you are, perhaps
>you just slept through that bit about the Constitution when you were
>in school... 
I'm a citizen of a country known as the United States of America, but 
AFAIK the Constitution of this country has no guarantees of justice or 
even equal treatment in our courts. Too bad - I wish it did. If you're 
from the same United States, perhaps you can point out to me the bits I 

  - Dennis


News | XML in Industry | Calendar | XML Registry
Marketplace | Resources | MyXML.org | Sponsors | Privacy Statement

Copyright 2001 XML.org. This site is hosted by OASIS