[
Lists Home |
Date Index |
Thread Index
]
"Bullard, Claude L (Len)" wrote:
>
> I agree with that. But your use and the use
> of your neighbor may be in conflict. You say
> your use governs, and as far as the spec says,
> it does. But practice is, the browser turns
> it blue and makes it clickable.
That's "my use". In practice, I want all URIs to be both locators and
identifiers. So I think the browser is doing the right thing.
> I believe that it is good practice when using a URL as a URI that one
> put something where it points for the sake of
> politeness,
I agree also.
>....
> If it is intended only to name: name it.
If it is intended only to name, surely there is some documentation that
goes with the name. So put it at the URI.
> If it is a name with an addressable referent, address it.
I agree. I think that there SHOULD always be an addressable referent,
except in corner cases or conscious choices not to document things.
> If it is or can be both, address it (leave a RDDL or
> RDF file there).
Agree.
> Leaving it dangling because in the future one might
> want to change it is somewhat like letting your
> 2 year old child into the neighbor's yard without diapers
> because you don't want to change them soon;
> or the neighbor letting the Rottweiler into yours because
> he may want to walk the dog later.
I don't understand either analogy but I do sense that they involve real
harm to someone. A 404 that lives for a few years *at best* causes
confusion, not real harm.
But anyhow, we are splitting hairs. The rule of thumb should be: "Use
HTTP URIS for namespaces. Put documentation at the referents, even if
only one sentence documentation." Where we disagree. I would say: "If,
for some reason, you are too lazy to do that, use HTTP URIs
nevertheless. You May change your mind about that laziness one day and
it makes no sense to burn your bridges."
--
"When I walk on the floor for the final execution, I'll wear a denim
suit. I'll walk in there like Willie Nelson, John Wayne, Will Smith
-- Men in Black -- James Brown. Maybe do a Michael Jackson moonwalk."
Congressman James Traficant.
|
