[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [xml-dev] Interoperability
At 11:33 AM 14/11/01 -0800, Joe English wrote:
>Earlier Sean quoted me as saying that I had given up
>on DTDs. I haven't at all; what I *have* given up on
>is <!DOCTYPE ...> declarations.
>URLs can break in too many ways.
>SYSTEM identifiers are a maintenance nightmare;
>Most importantly: it's very difficult to ensure that the URI
>for a DTD will last as long as the documents that reference it.
>Remember the time that Netscape reorganized their web site and
>all the headline aggregators on the Web suddenly stopped working?
>This sort of thing is an unacceptable risk.
All good points. But I don't think they have much to do with
interoperability of XML. You've pointed out what is a horrible
problem - the infrastructure has really lousy support for
dealing with multiple related resourcse that you need to
bring together to do a job. There are little bits & pieces
of machinery around: multipart-mime, RDDL, etc. Interestingly,
they tried to start a "packaging" activity up over at W3C but
it expired for lack of interest.
I've been kind of surprised that there isn't more energy
being pointed at this problem. Still am. -Tim